“Mothers of the Novel”: Women Writers before and beside Jane Austen

 

The history of the English novel is often told through a familiar male genealogy: Defoe, Richardson, Fielding, and then Jane Austen as the great technical finisher of the early realist tradition. Yet this account leaves a significant blind spot. Long before Austen’s novels appeared in print, women writers had already shaped prose fiction through romance, epistolary narrative, sentimental fiction, educational writing, Gothic romance, regional fiction, and the novel of manners. These women, who are commonly referred to as 'professional' in their literary lives (Peterson, 2009), did not merely occupy the margins of literary history. They helped create alternative traditions that expanded the formal, thematic, and social possibilities of the novel.

Aphra Behn and the Question of Origins

Virginia Woolf famously drew attention to this hidden lineage in A Room of One’s Own when she described Aphra Behn as a crucial predecessor for later women writers. Behn mattered not simply because she wrote, but because she wrote professionally. Woolf’s observation that Behn was “forced to live by her wits” identifies a decisive historical shift: a woman could earn money through writing and thus work, at least in principle, “on equal terms with men.” Behn, therefore, stands at the beginning of a female literary tradition that challenged the gendered restrictions of authorship.

Behn’s place in the rise of the novel remains complicated. Ian Watt’s influential criteria for realism prevent her from being treated straightforwardly as the first English novelist. Her works often retain the conventions of romance, heroic drama, and aristocratic intrigue rather than the formal realism associated with Defoe or Richardson. Nevertheless, Behn was an important predecessor. Love Letters between a Nobleman and His Sister brought the French epistolary tradition into English prose fiction decades before Richardson’s Pamela. Similarly, Oroonoko; or, The Royal Slave combined claims of authenticity with an exotic colonial setting, the tragic fate of a West African prince, and themes of race, slavery, colonialism, honour, and rebellion. Although Oroonoko does not fully move toward the realist novel, it introduced questions of empire and slavery into English prose narrative well before Robinson Crusoe. Its later stage adaptation by Thomas Southerne also helped sustain public attention to slavery and contributed indirectly to abolitionist discourse.

Women Writers between Behn and Austen

Feminist critics have therefore argued for a revision of the canon. Between Behn and Austen, numerous women writers participated actively in the development of prose fiction. Their work was not always formally radical in the same way as that of their male contemporaries, but it was often intertextual, collaborative, and generically innovative. Eliza Haywood, for example, was connected to Daniel Defoe through The Life of Mr Duncan Campbell and adapted Fielding’s Tom Thumb the Great as a comic opera. She also edited The Female Spectator, which looked back to the Addison and Steele essay tradition while creating a distinctly female periodical voice.

Sarah Fielding’s The Adventures of David Simple likewise shows the close interaction between male and female writers. Her brother Henry Fielding contributed a preface, but Sarah Fielding’s fiction pursued its own moral and sentimental interests. Charlotte Lennox’s The Female Quixote parodied romance by presenting a heroine who mistakes fictional conventions for reality, anticipating Austen’s later critique of Gothic and sentimental reading in Northanger Abbey. Frances Burney’s Evelina then became one of the most important precursors to Austen. Combining the sentimental novel, epistolary form, and the story of a young woman’s entrance into society, Burney helped establish a model for later female novels of development. Her influence extends beyond Austen to writers such as the Brontës, George Eliot, Kate Chopin, and Toni Morrison.

Educational Writing and Moral Fiction

Women also contributed to prose fiction through educational and religious writing. Mary Wollstonecraft is best known for A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, but her posthumously published The Wrongs of Woman reworked feminist arguments in fictional form. Hannah More, by contrast, used writing for moral and religious instruction. Her Cheap Repository Tracts reached a mass audience among the poor and barely literate, while her novel Coelebs in Search of a Wife became a bestseller. More’s deeply religious stance points toward literary Evangelicalism and the gradual formation of values later associated with Victorian morality.

'Oriental' Tales and the Exotic Imagination

At the same time, prose fiction was shaped by the popularity of Oriental tales and Gothic romances. The eighteenth century saw a fascination with exotic settings, particularly as the Ottoman Empire ceased to function as an immediate political threat to Western Europe. Orientalism became fashionable in aristocratic and literary circles. Montesquieu’s Persian Letters, Goldsmith’s Chinese Letters in The Citizen of the World, Lady Mary Wortley Montagu’s Turkish Embassy Letters, and Johnson’s Rasselas all used foreign or pseudo-foreign perspectives to reflect critically on European society, morality, happiness, and fortune.

William Beckford’s Vathek pushed the Oriental tale toward Gothic excess. Its Arabian setting becomes a space of sensuality, cruelty, supernatural terror, and moral transgression. Vathek’s Faustian pact with the ruler of the underworld and his willingness to slaughter children in pursuit of knowledge and experience show how Oriental settings were often exploited for fantasy, stereotype, and excess. Later Romantic writers, especially Byron, adapted Mediterranean and Oriental settings in verse narratives such as The Corsair and Childe Harold’s Pilgrimage. Byron’s Turkish tales helped create the Byronic hero and influenced the direction of Romantic narrative poetry, while Scott turned increasingly toward historical novels and romances.

Gothic Romance and Female Authorship

The Gothic romance was another crucial field in which women writers played a major role. Gothic fiction typically used remote historical periods, Mediterranean or Catholic settings, haunted castles, gloomy cloisters, aristocratic villains, endangered heroines, and supernatural intrusions. Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto provided the pattern for the genre, but Clara Reeve attempted to reform it in The Champion of Virtue by making the Gothic romance more credible and closer to sentimental fiction.

Ann Radcliffe became the most successful Gothic novelist of the 1790s and one of the highest-paid authors of her time. Her novels, especially The Mysteries of Udolpho and The Italian, refined the distinction between terror and horror. Terror, for Radcliffe, expands the soul and awakens the faculties; horror contracts and freezes them. Her fiction often explains apparently supernatural events rationally, and in this sense anticipates later discussions of magic realism, although formal realism was not her main aim. Instead, Radcliffe’s achievement lies in her handling of suspense, sublime landscapes, stereotyped but powerful emotional situations, and the conceptualization of Nature. Matthew Gregory Lewis’s The Monk offered a more sensational and explicit version of Gothic fiction, full of seduction, black magic, convent scandal, and direct supernatural intervention. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, published in 1818, later transformed Gothic romance into a philosophical and proto-scientific meditation on creation, responsibility, and monstrosity.

Irish Regional Fiction and the National Tale

Irish women writers also expanded the novel through regional and national fiction. Maria Edgeworth’s Castle Rackrent is one of the earliest regional novels of manners. Set before the year 1782, it presents the decline of the Irish landed gentry through the voice of Thady Quirk, a narrator whose apparent simplicity conceals his family’s own rise to power. Thady is an important example of the unreliable narrator, and the novel’s footnotes and glossary provide English readers with cultural and historical context. Edgeworth’s The Absentee continued her interest in Anglo-Irish relations. Sydney Owenson, Lady Morgan, developed similar concerns in The Wild Irish Girl, a national tale in which English protagonists travel to Ireland and confront inherited stereotypes about Irish Catholics. These regional novels became important models for Scott’s Waverley and for the historical novel more generally.

Jane Austen in Context

Jane Austen emerges from this complex field of women’s writing rather than standing outside it. In Watt’s account, she completes the line of Defoe, Richardson, Fielding, and Burney, but her work also belongs to a broader female tradition of epistolary fiction, satire, romance parody, conduct literature, and the novel of manners. Austen began writing in the 1790s, although her novels appeared in finalized form only between 1811 and 1818. Her unpublished epistolary novel Lady Susan shows her debt to Richardson’s Clarissa and Laclos’s Les Liaisons dangereuses, while the first draft of Pride and Prejudice, originally called First Impressions, suggests her early interest in perception, judgment, and social misunderstanding.

Austen’s fiction is often defined by its restricted social world. Raymond Williams criticized her for ignoring many of the major historical forces of her time: the Napoleonic wars, colonialism, slavery, industrialization, the working poor, London poverty, and the Celtic margins of Britain. This criticism is not entirely unfounded. Austen’s novels focus primarily on the middle classes and landed gentry, on courtship, marriage, inheritance, manners, and domestic sociability. Working life, sexuality, death, and politics remain largely outside the frame, although there are references to the slave trade in Mansfield Park and to the military context of the Napoleonic wars in Pride and Prejudice.

Yet Austen’s technical achievement lies precisely in what she does within this limited social field. Her novels turn dinner parties, balls, picnics, visits, walks, and conversations into instruments of moral and psychological analysis. Etiquette, propriety, decorum, and polite conversation become benchmarks by which character is tested. In Emma, for example, the heroine is “handsome, clever, and rich,” apparently blessed by fortune, but her intelligence and social power make her manipulative, self-deceiving, and morally fallible. Austen’s achievement is to make readers sympathize with Emma despite her egotism, while the gentler Jane Fairfax remains comparatively inaccessible.

This effect depends heavily on free indirect discourse. Austen’s narrative method allows the third-person narrator to move into a character’s consciousness while maintaining ironic distance. The result is psychological intimacy combined with dramatic irony. Austen’s narrator is less intrusive than Fielding’s, but still subtly controlling. Like Fielding, Austen remains a “confessed author,” shaping the reader’s moral response while creating an authenticity effect. The famous opening sentence of Pride and Prejudice — “It is a truth universally acknowledged…” — transforms the eighteenth-century tradition of ironic generalization into a concise social and comic principle.

Austen’s moral vision often depends on balance. Pride and Prejudice rejects both marriage as mere convenience, represented by Charlotte Lucas and Mr Collins, and uncontrolled romantic passion, represented by Lydia and Wickham. The unhappy marriage of Mr and Mrs Bennet further shows the long-term consequences of attraction without judgment. Austen’s ideal lies in a middle ground: emotion governed by reason, or, in the terms of her first published novel, sense joined to sensibility. The marriages of Jane and Bingley, and Elizabeth and Darcy, suggest that happiness requires affection, self-knowledge, moral education, and social compatibility.

Austen as Heiress, Not Exception

In this sense, Austen is both an inheritor and a transformer of earlier traditions. She draws on Richardson’s epistolary psychological depth, Fielding’s irony, Burney’s female Bildungsroman, Lennox’s parody of romance, and the comedy of manners. At the same time, she anticipates later realist fiction through her subtle use of free indirect discourse and her precise mapping of social consciousness. She can even be seen as a missing link between Restoration comedy of manners and the witty social comedies of Oscar Wilde.

The “mothers of the novel” therefore deserve more than supplementary mention. From Aphra Behn’s professional authorship and colonial romance to Burney’s female development narrative, Radcliffe’s Gothic suspense, Edgeworth’s regional realism, and Austen’s ironic novel of manners, women writers were central to the formation of English prose fiction. They broadened the novel’s themes, experimented with its forms, and created traditions that stood before, beside, and beyond the canonical male line. To understand the rise of the novel fully, one must recover this female genealogy and recognize that Austen was not an isolated exception but the brilliant heir to a rich and varied tradition of women’s writing.

---

More on literature in Britain

• Before Derry Girls, There Was An Béal Bocht: Ireland’s Satirical Classic
• Maria Edgeworth’s The Absentee and the Politics of Irish Identity